Last night after the play, before we'd heard Tony Curtis had passed away, I was telling someone a story about him. Mr. Curtis was, of course, a great movie star but there were those who said that what he wasn't was an actor. I once heard a prominent teacher of actors say precisely that, citing him as an example of someone who sought and achieved stardom and fame and fortune without ever really learning his craft. She said this to a roomful of acting students, some of whom didn't see anything wrong with that. Or if they did, it was that the limitation may have made that fame and fortune short-lived.
Anyway, I got to telling the story of what had happened when Neil Simon wrote a play called I Ought to Be In Pictures and decided that despite a total lack of stage experience, Tony Curtis was just the guy to star in it. Simon called Tony's agent, who I think was the legendary "Swifty" Lazar. Let's say it was him. Lazar said, "Neil, Tony's my client but you're my friend and my advice is not to take him. I don't think this will end well." Simon asked why. The agent declined to explain. He said, "But if you want him, I'll recommend he do it." Simon decided to take the gamble and Curtis was hired. Curtis, who'd never done anything of this sort, was nervous but excited about making his Broadway debut. He demanded and got a private acting coach to help him learn his lines and he called Simon every night to talk through the part, ask questions and mostly be reassured. Dinah Manoff was playing his daughter, by the way.
They opened with an outta-town tryout. The town was Los Angeles and it was down at the Music Center — I forget which theater. The Ahmanson, probably. Curtis was at least passable opening night and after the show, Simon went back and said something like, "You did fine, Tony. And it'll go even better once I do the rewrite." Simon was, of course, referring to the fact that once an audience sees a new show, the playwright usually rewrites whole scenes and speeches. Neil Simon is famous for doing a lot of that, including tossing out entire acts and writing new ones.
At first mention of the rewrite, Curtis paled. He said, "What do you mean? This is the show I learned. This is the show we're doing." It was explained to him but he insisted he'd learned that script and could not possibly learn changes. He was told he'd have to.
I saw the show a few nights later…apparently before they'd given him any. It was a nice, unmemorable evening — not one of Mr. Simon's stronger efforts but we were all entertained. Tony Curtis was okay in the play but Dinah Manoff was better. It was however possible to imagine Curtis would improve by the time the show got to Broadway.
That did not happen. When they began giving Curtis new dialogue, he couldn't learn it and he lost the unchanged lines. One night he went out and began ad-libbing (poorly) what he couldn't remember, getting angrier and angrier when the other actors on stage said things to him and he couldn't recall what to say in response. He began cursing them out and spewing out-of-character vulgarities and the entire first act was a shambles. At intermission, he solved the problem by getting back into his street clothes and going home…and when I Ought to Be In Pictures opened on Broadway, his role was being played by Ron Liebman.
Thereafter, Curtis concentrated on film and TV work. I didn't see everything he did, before or after, so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt. Maybe he did something that demonstrated great ability. He wasn't bad in The Boston Strangler but for the most part, he seemed to define the difference between being an Actor and a Movie Star. I'm not saying that's a bad thing. I just think it's important sometimes to recognize the distinction.
I met him briefly a couple of times, long after the stardom had cooled. Our longest conversation was at a book/photo signing and during a lull in the line, we chatted about a failed project that would have brought him back to the stage and (eventually and finally) to Broadway. It was to be a revival of the musical, Li'l Abner. He was to serve as one of the producers and to play several small roles, popping up (he explained) like Frank Morgan appearing in The Wizard of Oz above and beyond the title role. He explained to me how the deal fell apart but I frankly didn't understand it…and then people came over to ask for his autograph and he was more interested in that than in our conversation. He was very good at giving autographs, by the way. He was charming and self-deprecating and he made the signature-seekers feel they'd had a very special moment with a very special Movie Star. And when I think of him today, I think of how happy he made those people…and how happy they made him.