Last night, August 7th, 2007 was the first performance before a full audience of Mel Brooks' new musical, Young Frankenstein, at the magnificent Paramount Theatre in Seattle, Washington and we were there. Seattle has become a "try-out" town where musicals such as Hairspray and plays like Angels in America have their pre-Broadway runs before heading to New York just as they used to do in New Haven and Boston. It was a treat to see this big, big show in our wonderful town, forgive the pun.
In a nutshell, it's going to be a big hit, as big, if not bigger, than Brooks' The Producers. Young Frankenstein is a three-hour romp, staged at a breakneck pace. There's hardly a pause in the action. Whether you loved the movie or never saw it (there are those people) you'll be more than satisfied and you'll have a great evening in the theatre.
It has a number of things going for it. It's almost a beat-for-beat reproduction of the Young Frankenstein movie complete with all the scenes and jokes we know and love from "what knockers" to "where wolves, there wolves" and the inevitable whinny after each mention of Frau Blucher. This is not a bad thing. It works. I would have to re-run the movie (not a bad idea) to be sure but it seemed to me that everything from the movie was included. There were a few extra moments and, of course, about twenty new musical numbers (music and lyrics by Brooks) some of which worked but some of which were a puzzle. The ones that didn't work will get cut or trimmed since the running time is about twenty minutes too long, especially in the first act which runs an hour and forty minutes and since they're in try-out mode anyway. Incidentally, we're going back to see the official opening on the August 23rd and it will be very interesting to see the "improvements."
The evening belongs to Susan Stroman, the choreographer and director. She has staged it wonderfully and made almost every musical number a rouser. The "eleven o'clock number" is "Putting on the Ritz," a number that will be remembered by theatre-goers as long as they live much like us oldsters remember "Fugue for Tinhorns," "There is Nothing Like a Dame" or "With a Little Bit of Luck" from the great musicals of the past. The "Ritz" number incorporates elements of the Fred Astaire version in Blue Skies (1946), including the line-up of dancers behind Astaire mimicking his every move. They also use the "Me and My Shadow" gimmick to great effect. Stroman builds this number beautifully from the moment when there are only two people on stage to the climax when the entire cast is involved. It's a great number, as are many others.
Stroman has also staged the comedy scenes with a strong sense of how to lay out the jokes and present the physical comedy. She is aided by a wonderful cast who sing and dance with great skill and are very adept at comedy. There isn't anybody in the cast who is wrong for the part and if casting is 90% of a production's success, they've struck gold.
Oddly enough, Christopher Fitzgerald emerges as the most appealing and funny character as Igor, he of the movable hump. Fitzgerald, as do all of the actors, reminds us of the originals (in this case, Marty Feldman) but has a stronger appeal than Feldman in creating a sympathetic character. He has an English accent and it's startling to hear a voice that sounds like Feldman's come from Igor but you soon get used to it. Fitzgerald is also a strong singer and dancer and a bundle of energy. He rules the stage.
In the Gene Wilder part, Roger Bart, holds back on the zaniness that Wilder had (especially in the moment when Frankenstein decides to follow in his grandfather's footsteps) but he handles the role competently. It's not an easy role, which calls for our liking and understanding him while laughing at his antics. Bart is fine, though, and ignore my quibbles.
I'm sorry to say that the beautiful Sutton Foster, who was wonderful in The Drowsy Chaperone, doesn't do much with Inga, the Teri Garr part. Actually, she doesn't have much to do except aid and abet young Frankenstein and Igor. When she does have something to do, as in the "Roll in the Hay" number she shows her chops, singing and dancing wonderfully.
Andrea Martin as Frau Blücher (horse whinny) really delivers, as we should expect from this wonderful actress. She belts out the musical number "He Vas My Boyfriend" and stops the show. (Of course, everyone belts out his or her numbers. That may not bode well for audience members who needs a breather.) Martin is a treasure and makes the most of every moment.
Shuler Hensley, who was the only good "Poor Jud" in Oklahoma I ever saw, assays the monster and, again the inevitable comparison to the late Peter Boyle, brings the creature to life. (Stop me before I pun again.) He can sing. The Monster can sing! And dance, too.
Now, to Megan Mullally who plays Elizabeth, she of the "don't touch me" persona. In fact she sings a song called "Please Don't Touch Me." Mullaly is a true musical comedy star with a voice that could shatter glass. She plays Elizabeth with the archness that we've come to expect from the TV series Will and Grace and is a perfect successor to Madeline Kahn in this role. However, if you'll recall from the movie, Elizabeth disappears for a good amount of time emerging towards the end to fall for the creature and help the love plot. Since they're dealing here with a major star (Mullally) they've had to insert Elizabeth to no great effect in a couple of "fantasy" sequences in the middle of the plot which don't quite work. She does them well, of course, but you wonder why they are there. It'll be interesting to see what becomes of these numbers and whether Mullally will be happy with the results.
Fred Applegate plays both Kemp, the Inspector, and the blind hermit. He is fine as both, especially in a lovely song the hermit sings about loneliness, "Please Send Me Someone" which is capped by the creature smashing through the wall of his hut. Why he plays both parts is a mystery except that he does have an excellent singing voice which Kemp never really reveals. But the make-up change is huge from Kemp-to-hermit and why they don't have another actor in the hermit part is a puzzle.
The chorus boys and girls are all exceptional and makes me wish I had studied harder in ballet school. (Just kidding.) And the other small parts are well done. No quibbles there.
A great deal of the success of Young Frankenstein has to be attributed to the phenomenal set and lighting design. Even though last night was the first preview there were only one or two small gaffes in the set changes and lighting with huge sets, props and backdrops flying in with ease. The set for Frankenstein's laboratory is a triumph. They even have an electrostatic generator and I think I saw a Tesla coil. Lightning flashes and thunder roars and strobe lights flash when they bring the creature to life. It is an evocation of that wonderful cinematic moment in the original Frankenstein as well as Brooks' Young Frankenstein. It's worth the price of admission for that set alone. They could ease off on the strobe lights, though, as many of us had to shield our eyes from time to time.
As far as the songs are concerned there are no memorable ones to take with you. Most of them serve the plot and are joke-filled so even if a current recording artist (are there any?) released a recording of one of the songs it would die a quick…and deserved…death. Brooks lacks the musical skill to write a strong melody and, as I said, the lyrics are plot pushers or joke fests. You leave the theatre humming the sets and the costumes rather than the songs.
The plot and jokes are standard Mel Brooks, which is not a bad thing. He tends to be vulgar, as you know, and if you can live with his kind of humor you'll laugh and not be offended. What next? Blazing Saddles? Twelve Chairs? High Anxiety? Probably not but I'm happy with Young Frankenstein. And you'll have a grand time, too.