Comes now a nice message from Dave Mackey, one of several one-time collectors of Castle Films who have graced my e-mailbox since I veered off onto the topic. Here's Dave…
Our family acquired an Argus 8mm projector and camera outfit in 1968. Naturally, we made our own home movies, many of which are still within the family (I think [my brother] Robair has them), and we also had the Castle Films. Of course, we had the 50-foot version of Have Badge, Will Chase yet never connected it to A&C Meet The Keystone Kops, though we all saw the A&C films over and over again every Sunday morning on Channel 11. We also had a Woody Woodpecker film, Puny Express (1951), which for some odd reason was packaged in a box advertising a later Inspector Willoughby cartoon, Phoney Express (1962). We also had representative reels from Columbia's 8mm program, which mostly featured Three Stooges shorts, and Ken Films, which marketed the pre-48 WB cartoons on 8mm.
Castle made 16mm films available too, as 16mm was also a viable home format for a while. The bane of many cartoon collectors is the plethora of Castle-titled Walter Lantz cartoons that often don't have correct opens and closes and often leave off production credits. (Some were even censored, as in the case of Abou Ben Boogie and a few other titles which had, um, modifications.)
But the 8mm format was a dream to cartoon collectors: when I worked in a department store camera department in my teens, I had access to a near-complete collection of Lantz 8mm color/sound prints, which were then marketed under the name Universal 8, with Betamax and VHS merely a blip on the horizon and DVD's not even imaginable at that point. Features on 8mm? Only if you were really lucky. Cartoons on 8mm? Oh yes!
One of the games/frustrations of collecting 8mm films was in the title changes. Castle chopped Abbott and Costello Meet the Keystone Kops into at least two short films…Have Badge, Will Chase and Hollywood and Bust. You had to kind of guess that No Bulls, Please was a cut from Mexican Hayride or that Double Cross at Criss-Cross was a drastic condensation of The Wistful Widow of Wagon Gap.
No Fires, Please, was a cutdown of Fireman, Save My Child, which was the Abbott and Costello film that Universal made without Abbott or Costello. It was written for them and some very elaborate stunt scenes were filmed with the appropriate stuntmen. Then, Bud and Lou refused to make it so Universal cast Hugh O'Brian and Buddy Hackett…a rare case of the stars being selected to match the stunt people, instead of vice-versa.
I remember a friend of mine who loved the Laurel and Hardy silent film, Liberty, and he was thrilled when he saw it listed in the catalogue of Atlas Films, which was one of the cheezier purveyors of 8mm movies. But Liberty was a two-reel film and Atlas had it in a one-reel version. He guessed that another film in their list, Trouser Trouble, might be the first reel of Liberty since Stan and Ollie never made a real film called Trouser Trouble and since the first half of Liberty is pretty much about them somehow getting each other's pants on and trying to find a private place to make the swap.
He ordered both films and was delighted to find that Trouser Trouble was the first half of Liberty and the film they sold under the name of Liberty was the second half…except that about four minutes was missing between the two reels…a scene where Hardy accidentally gets a live crab in his britches.
Further inspection of the Atlas catalogue showed that they were selling a 50-foot Laurel and Hardy film with the name, Crab Bait…another title that never existed in The Boys' official filmography. My friend sent off for it and, sure enough, it filled in the missing four minutes. He chopped off the title card footage that Atlas had created for two of the three films, spliced the main title from the one-reel Liberty onto the front of Trouser Trouble, spliced Crab Bait onto the beginning of Liberty…and he had a complete, two-reel 8mm copy of Liberty. Whew.